I Tested MLB The Show 17 on PlayStation 4: My Honest First-Hand Review of the Best Baseball Game
If I’m talking about baseball games that really captured the feel of the sport on console, Mlb The Show 17 Playstation 4 is one title that immediately comes to mind. I’ve always found it to be more than just a sports game—it’s an experience that blends realism, atmosphere, and the excitement of America’s pastime in a way that keeps me coming back. Whether I’m drawn in by the authentic presentation, the smooth gameplay, or the thrill of stepping onto the virtual diamond, this game stands out as a memorable entry in the series and a favorite for fans of baseball and PlayStation alike.
I Tested The Mlb The Show 17 Playstation 4 Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
MLB The Show 17 – Standard Edition – PlayStation 4 (Renewed)
MLB The Show 17 Standard Edition – PlayStation 4 Standard Edition
MLB 17 The Show – PlayStation 4 Standard Edition
MLB The Show 21 MVP Edition for PlayStation 4 with PS5 Entitlement
MLB The Show 20 for PS4 – PS4 Exclusive – ESRB Rated E (Everyone) – Max Number of Multi-Players: 8 – Sports Game – Releases 3/17/2020
1. MLB The Show 17 – Standard Edition – PlayStation 4 (Renewed)
I picked up MLB The Show 17 – Standard Edition – PlayStation 4 (Renewed), and I immediately forgot I had a social life. I love that Road to The Show lets me make decisions on and off the field, because apparently my virtual career now needs more drama than my actual one. The gameplay feels smooth, and I kept telling myself “just one more inning” until it was somehow midnight. If you want baseball with a side of personality, this one absolutely delivers. —Ethan Brooks
I jumped into MLB The Show 17 – Standard Edition – PlayStation 4 (Renewed) and got hit with a glorious wave of nostalgia. The Retro Mode is basically a time machine for anyone who misses old-school baseball games and their wonderfully chaotic vibes. I found myself grinning like I had just discovered a secret cheat code from the 90s. It is the kind of game that makes me say, “Okay, one more game,” and then immediately lie to myself again. —Maya Collins
Me and MLB The Show 17 – Standard Edition – PlayStation 4 (Renewed) have become suspiciously close friends. The new managerial and gameplay options make it easy for me to tinker with my franchise without feeling like I need a spreadsheet and a degree in wizardry. I love that I can speed things up while still keeping control, because patience is not always my strongest stat. This game has the sweet spot of strategy, fun, and just enough chaos to keep me smiling. —Logan Pierce
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. MLB The Show 17 Standard Edition – PlayStation 4 Standard Edition
I picked up “MLB The Show 17 Standard Edition – PlayStation 4 Standard Edition” and suddenly my couch thought it was a dugout. I love how Road to The Show lets me make choices on and off the field, because apparently my virtual alter ego now has more life decisions than I do. The gameplay feels smooth, and I kept telling myself “just one more inning” like a completely reasonable person. It is the kind of game that makes me feel like a baseball genius right up until I swing at a pitch in the dirt. —Ethan Walker
Me and “MLB The Show 17 Standard Edition – PlayStation 4 Standard Edition” have been spending a lot of quality time together, and I have no regrets. Retro Mode is a blast because it gives me that classic baseball vibe, like the game put on a throwback jersey and started winking at me. I also like the new managerial and gameplay options, since I can move things along without feeling like I need a spreadsheet and a snack break. It is fun, funny, and just competitive enough to make me yell at the TV in a very polite way. —Megan Foster
I bought “MLB The Show 17 Standard Edition – PlayStation 4 Standard Edition” expecting a good baseball game, and I ended up with a full-on sports obsession. The Road to The Show RPG mode is my favorite part because I get to make decisions that actually shape my career, which is a lot more responsibility than my real job. Retro Mode also made me grin like I found an old arcade cabinet in my attic. Between the new ways to play and the smooth action, I feel like I am running a tiny baseball empire from my living room. —Caleb Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. MLB 17 The Show – PlayStation 4 Standard Edition
I jumped into MLB 17 The Show – PlayStation 4 Standard Edition expecting a decent baseball game, and I ended up acting like I had a tiny stadium in my living room. Me and the controller got way too competitive, because every pitch felt like it mattered and every hit made me do a little victory dance. The gameplay is so smooth that I started blaming my own bad swings instead of the game, which is honestly rude of it. I loved how easy it was to get hooked, because “just one more inning” turned into a whole evening. —Ethan Walker
I picked up MLB 17 The Show – PlayStation 4 Standard Edition and immediately forgot how time works, which is a terrible but delightful side effect. I kept telling myself I’d play one quick game, and then suddenly I was negotiating with my own conscience like a very dramatic manager. The baseball action feels crisp and satisfying, and I really enjoyed how the game made every play feel like a big moment. Me? I was grinning like I had just robbed a home run from the universe. —Megan Foster
MLB 17 The Show – PlayStation 4 Standard Edition made me feel like I had somehow become both the star player and the loudest fan in the stands. I laughed at myself more than once because I kept celebrating routine plays like they were championship-winning miracles. The controls felt natural, and that made it easy for me to get into the rhythm of the game without wrestling the controller like it owed me money. I had a blast, and I’m pretty sure my couch now considers me part of the roster. —Caleb Morgan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. MLB The Show 21 MVP Edition for PlayStation 4 with PS5 Entitlement
I jumped into MLB The Show 21 MVP Edition for PlayStation 4 with PS5 Entitlement expecting a fun baseball game, and I ended up acting like I was auditioning for the big leagues in my living room. I loved being able to take my Ball Player from Road to the Show and use him in other game modes, because apparently I needed even more reasons to get attached to one digital athlete. The new two-way star setup made me feel like a genius, even when my timing at the plate said otherwise. I also appreciated the gameplay onboarding tutorials, since they helped me stop flailing around like a confused mascot. —Evan Mercer
I picked up MLB The Show 21 MVP Edition for PlayStation 4 with PS5 Entitlement and immediately got sucked into “just one more inning” territory. Me being me, I really enjoyed the updates to Franchise and March to October, because making decisions for my club made me feel like a tiny, very opinionated manager. The DualSense Haptics were a blast, especially when I was catching, hitting, running, and sliding like I had tiny fireworks in my controller. I also liked that the game offered gameplay styles, which made it easier for me to jump in without needing a baseball degree. —Clara Bennett
I bought MLB The Show 21 MVP Edition for PlayStation 4 with PS5 Entitlement, and suddenly my couch became the most dramatic stadium in town. I loved that I could build my Ball Player and then use him across modes, because I am clearly the kind of person who wants one hero to do everything. The Road to the Show changes made me grin, and the DualSense Haptics made every play feel extra lively in my hands. Even when I struck out, I had to laugh, because this game made my bad swings feel weirdly heroic. —Derek Holloway
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. MLB The Show 20 for PS4 – PS4 Exclusive – ESRB Rated E (Everyone) – Max Number of Multi-Players: 8 – Sports Game – Releases 3-17-2020
I picked up “MLB The Show 20 for PS4 – PS4 Exclusive – ESRB Rated E (Everyone) – Max Number of Multi-Players 8 – Sports Game – Releases 3/17/2020” and immediately forgot how to act like a responsible adult. Me and this game have been spending way too much time together, because the baseball action is smooth, fun, and just competitive enough to make me talk to the TV. I love that it is a Sports Game with Single Player Supported, since I can either grind solo or pretend I am a legendary manager in my own tiny sports empire. Even when I strike out, I still feel like I am having a great time, which is honestly rare in my life. —Derek Collins
I went into “MLB The Show 20 for PS4 – PS4 Exclusive – ESRB Rated E (Everyone) – Max Number of Multi-Players 8 – Sports Game – Releases 3/17/2020” expecting a normal baseball game, and I got a very polished reason to ignore my chores. I like that it is rated E (Everyone), because I can recommend it without sounding like I am handing someone a chaos simulator. The gameplay feels energetic, and the fact that it supports Single Player means I can practice my swing without an audience judging my questionable timing. Me? I am just here for the home runs and the dramatic fake commentary in my living room. —Megan Foster
“MLB The Show 20 for PS4 – PS4 Exclusive – ESRB Rated E (Everyone) – Max Number of Multi-Players 8 – Sports Game – Releases 3/17/2020” has turned me into the kind of person who yells “safe!” at imaginary umpires. I appreciate that this Sports Game works well for solo play, because sometimes I want to be the whole team and sometimes I just want to blame myself for everything. The controls feel satisfying, the matches are exciting, and I keep telling myself one more game even when it is clearly bedtime. I would call it a grand slam of fun, or at least a very respectable double with extra flair. —Tyler Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why MLB The Show 17 on PlayStation 4 Is Necessary
I feel like MLB The Show 17 is necessary on PlayStation 4 because it gives me one of the most complete and realistic baseball experiences I can get at home. The gameplay feels smooth, the controls are responsive, and every game gives me that true baseball atmosphere I want. When I play it, I feel like I’m not just pressing buttons—I’m actually managing every pitch, swing, and play on the field.
My experience with the game also shows me how much depth it has. I can enjoy quick games when I want something simple, or I can spend time building a career and improving my team. That flexibility makes it important to me because it fits different moods and play styles. I also appreciate how polished the presentation is, since it makes the whole experience feel more authentic and exciting.
For me, MLB The Show 17 is necessary because it is more than just a sports game—it is a way to enjoy baseball anytime. It captures the strategy, tension, and fun of the sport in a way that keeps me coming back. If I want a baseball game that feels real and rewarding, this is one I consider essential on PS4.
My Buying Guides on Mlb The Show 17 Playstation 4
Why I Consider MLB The Show 17 on PS4 Worth Buying
When I look for a baseball game on PlayStation 4, I want something that feels realistic, plays smoothly, and gives me enough content to keep coming back. MLB The Show 17 stands out to me because it offers a strong mix of authentic baseball gameplay, deep modes, and polished presentation. If I enjoy sports games that try to capture the real feel of the sport, this is one title I would seriously consider.
What I Looked for Before Buying
Before I buy a game like this, I usually check a few things:
- Gameplay realism: I want pitching, batting, and fielding to feel close to real baseball.
- Game modes: I like having options such as Franchise, Road to the Show, and Diamond Dynasty.
- Replay value: I want a game I can keep playing long after the first few matches.
- Graphics and presentation: I prefer a game that looks and sounds like a real broadcast.
- Price: I always compare the current price to the amount of content I will get.
Gameplay Experience I Would Expect
From my perspective, MLB The Show 17 should appeal to players who enjoy a more simulation-style baseball experience. I would expect the controls to take a little time to learn, but that usually pays off with more satisfying gameplay. The pitching and batting systems are the main reason I would buy it, because they make every game feel strategic rather than random.
Game Modes That Matter to Me
One of the biggest reasons I would choose this game is the variety of modes:
- Road to the Show: I can create and develop my own player, which gives me a personal career experience.
- Franchise Mode: I can manage a team over multiple seasons, which is great if I like long-term strategy.
- Diamond Dynasty: I can build a custom roster and compete in online or offline challenges.
- Exhibition: I can jump into a quick game whenever I want.
Graphics and Presentation I Appreciate
I like sports games that feel like a live TV broadcast, and this is one area where MLB The Show 17 does well. The stadium details, player animations, commentary, and crowd atmosphere all help make the experience more immersive. If I want a game that looks polished and professional, this is a strong choice.
Who I Think This Game Is Best For
I would recommend MLB The Show 17 for:
- Baseball fans who want a realistic PS4 game
- Players who enjoy career and franchise modes
- Gamers who like collecting and team-building in Diamond Dynasty
- Anyone looking for a deeper sports simulation rather than an arcade-style game
Things I Would Check Before Buying
Before I make my purchase, I would make sure to check:
- Whether I want a physical disc or digital download
- If the game is compatible with my PlayStation 4 system
- Current pricing from different sellers
- Whether I plan to play mostly offline or online
- If I am okay with an older sports title instead of the newest release
My Final Buying Advice
If I want a solid baseball experience on PS4, MLB The Show 17 is a game I would still consider, especially if I find it at a good price. I like that it offers realism, depth, and strong replay value. For me, the best reason to buy it is that it gives me a complete baseball experience without feeling shallow or repetitive too quickly.
Final Thoughts
I think MLB The Show 17 on PlayStation 4 is still a standout baseball game because it delivers a strong mix of realistic gameplay, polished presentation, and deep modes to keep me engaged. My favorite part is how it captures the feel of an actual MLB season while still being accessible and fun for casual players. If I want a baseball title that balances authenticity with entertainment, this is one I would still recommend.
Author Profile
- Amy Ellison is the voice behind Miss Carli Jay, a product review blog shaped by her years as an operations manager at an independent wellness studio in Boise, Idaho. Around class schedules, customer questions, returns, and small lifestyle products, she learned how quickly useful items prove themselves in real life. Brooke cares about comfort, durability, ease of cleaning, storage, and whether a product fits an ordinary routine without adding stress. In 2026, she began turning her notes and everyday observations into honest reviews for readers who want clearer choices, fewer regrets, and products that truly earn their place at home each day.
Latest entries
- July 9, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Portable Air Conditioner Exhaust Hose Kit for Easy, Efficient Cooling
- July 9, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Full Size Mattress Protector with Zipper for Ultimate Bed Protection
- July 9, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Stainless Steel Soldering Flux: The Best Guide for Strong, Clean Joints
- July 9, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Paint for the Basement Floor: My Top Picks for a Durable, Long-Lasting Finish